You are here

Kevin Jardine's blog

Some Like It Hot, Part 5, A revised face-on map within 3kpc using Gaia DR2

Submitted by Kevin Jardine on 12 May, 2018 - 16:38
Face-on map of Milky Way
A face-on map of the Milky Way within 3kpc (about 10 thousand light years). The full revised map is is available as a PDF here.

I have revised the face-on map I published in my last blog post. As before, this is based on the Humphreys/Blaha data set of ionizing and highly luminous stars and a (now expanded) list of ionizing stars for HII regions. For this revision, I used the distance estimates for Gaia DR2 stars provided by Bailer-Jones and his colleagues at Germany's Max Planck Institute for Astronomy. These distances provide more accurate distance estimates for many stars than a simple reciprocal calculation, and allow distances to be estimated for a much larger set of stars.

In order to provide an additional check on the HII region distances, I have compared the Bailer-Jones distances for the ionizing stars with existing photometric and kinematic distance estimates for the associated HII regions. If a photometric or kinematic distance estimate provided an error range, I used that, or otherwise used a range of +/- 25% of the published value.

If an ionizing star had a Bailer-Jones distance outside the error range for any published distance estimate for the associated HII region, I considered it an outlier and filtered it out. I then computed a filtered distance for the HII region as the median distance for the filtered ionizing stars. If 50% or more of the ionizing stars for an HII region made it through the filtering process, I used the filtered distance value for the revised map. If less than 50% of the ionizing stars for an HII region made it through the filtering process, I excluded the HII region from the map.

For a small number of HII regions with very bright ionizing stars I used Hipparcos stars with err/plx < 0.2 when Gaia DR data was not available. I used the reciprocal method to compute the distance and then applied the same filtering process described above.

Fortunately, almost all the major HII regions within 3kpc made it through the filtering process. The ones that did not were mostly small regions with few known ionizing stars. I have added a table below listing the HII regions that had at least one ionizing star with a Bailer-Jones distance compatible with a previously published HII region distance. I provided links to the relevant distance papers in the last column of the table.

The full revised map is is available as a PDF here. You will need to zoom into about 200% in the PDF to read the labels for each HII region.

You can also see the list of ionizing stars I used for the HII regions.

Region All distance All star count Filtered distance Filtered star count Percentage Sources
Sh 2-275 1508 6 1508 6 100% [1], [2]
Gum 38a 2574 4 2574 4 100% [1], [2], [3]
RCW 14 2778 4 2778 4 100% [1]
RCW 32 962 4 962 4 100% [1], [2]
Sh 2-157 3209 4 3209 4 100% [1], [2], [3]
Sh 2-299 4182 4 4182 4 100% [1], [2]
Sh 2-300 4182 4 4182 4 100% [1], [2]
Sh 2-306 4959 4 4959 4 100% [1], [2], [3]
DWB 78 1652 3 1652 3 100% [1]
Gum 21 2228 3 2228 3 100% [1]
RCW 104 3505 3 3505 3 100% [1]
Sh 2-150 982 3 982 3 100% [1], [2]
Sh 2-205 1141 3 1141 3 100% [1], [2], [3], [4]
Sh 2-219 4025 3 4025 3 100% [1], [2], [3], [4]
Sh 2-252 2174 3 2174 3 100% [1], [2], [3], [4]
Sh 2-254 2376 3 2376 3 100% [1], [2], [3], [4]
Sh 2-255 2376 3 2376 3 100% [1], [2], [3], [4]
Sh 2-256 2376 3 2376 3 100% [1], [2], [3], [4]
Sh 2-257 2376 3 2376 3 100% [1], [2], [3], [4]
Sh 2-258 2376 3 2376 3 100% [1], [2], [3], [4]
Ge 129 1999 2 1999 2 100% [1]
RCW 113 1545 2 1545 2 100% [1], [2], [3]
RCW 117 1470 2 1470 2 100% [1]
RCW 19 4091 2 4091 2 100% [1], [2]
RCW 41 2027 2 2027 2 100% [1]
RCW 47 2637 2 2637 2 100% [1], [2], [3], [4]
RCW 60a 2674 2 2674 2 100% [1]
RCW 75 2404 2 2404 2 100% [1], [2]
RCW 82 3280 2 3280 2 100% [1], [2]
RCW 88 2348 2 2348 2 100% [1]
Sh 2-139 3453 2 3453 2 100% [1], [2], [3], [4]
Sh 2-142 2964 2 2964 2 100% [1]
Sh 2-184 2306 2 2306 2 100% [1], [2]
Sh 2-217 4025 2 4025 2 100% [1], [2], [3], [4]
Sh 2-25 1195 2 1195 2 100% [1]
Sh 2-29 1072 2 1072 2 100% [1]
Sh 2-307 4054 2 4054 2 100% [1]
Sh 2-309 4959 2 4959 2 100% [1], [2], [3]
Sh 2-311 6450 2 6450 2 100% [1], [2]
Sh 2-34 1602 2 1602 2 100% [1]
Sh 2-4 3295 2 3295 2 100% [1], [2], [3]
Sh 2-92 3795 2 3795 2 100% [1], [2]
BFS 28 915 1 915 1 100% [1]
BFS 54 1514 1 1514 1 100% [1]
BFS 63 1090 1 1090 1 100% [1]
DWB 155 1659 1 1659 1 100% [1]
Ge 130 2910 1 2910 1 100% [1]
Gum 31 3289 1 3289 1 100% [1], [2], [3]
H 36 2773 1 2773 1 100% [1]
L 4 4455 1 4455 1 100% [1]
RCW 107 1101 1 1101 1 100% [1], [2]
RCW 108 1049 1 1049 1 100% [1], [2]
RCW 110 1900 1 1900 1 100% [1]
RCW 114 1154 1 1154 1 100% [1]
RCW 119 1749 1 1749 1 100% [1], [2]
RCW 125 1433 1 1433 1 100% [1], [2]
RCW 51 2566 1 2566 1 100% [1], [2], [3]
RCW 71 1608 1 1608 1 100% [1]
RCW 94 1779 1 1779 1 100% [1]
Sh 2-117 668 1 668 1 100% [1]
Sh 2-13 1039 1 1039 1 100% [1]
Sh 2-134 612 1 612 1 100% [1]
Sh 2-135 2252 1 2252 1 100% [1]
Sh 2-15 1249 1 1249 1 100% [1], [2]
Sh 2-155 831 1 831 1 100% [1], [2], [3]
Sh 2-158 2671 1 2671 1 100% [1], [2], [3], [4]
Sh 2-160 912 1 912 1 100% [1], [2]
Sh 2-162 2495 1 2495 1 100% [1], [2], [3]
Sh 2-163 3473 1 3473 1 100% [1], [2]
Sh 2-164 2840 1 2840 1 100% [1], [2], [3], [4]
Sh 2-165 1715 1 1715 1 100% [1], [2], [3]
Sh 2-168 2705 1 2705 1 100% [1], [2]
Sh 2-170 1887 1 1887 1 100% [1], [2]
Sh 2-173 3021 1 3021 1 100% [1], [2], [3], [4], [5]
Sh 2-175 2121 1 2121 1 100% [1]
Sh 2-180 4732 1 4732 1 100% [1], [2], [3]
Sh 2-185 168 1 168 1 100% [1], [2]
Sh 2-198 2176 1 2176 1 100% [1], [2], [3]
Sh 2-206 3135 1 3135 1 100% [1], [2], [3], [4]
Sh 2-207 3532 1 3532 1 100% [1], [2]
Sh 2-22 1082 1 1082 1 100% [1]
Sh 2-223 6602 1 6602 1 100% [1]
Sh 2-227 4259 1 4259 1 100% [1], [2], [3]
Sh 2-229 401 1 401 1 100% [1], [2]
Sh 2-232 2068 1 2068 1 100% [1], [2]
Sh 2-235 1651 1 1651 1 100% [1]
Sh 2-237 4139 1 4139 1 100% [1]
Sh 2-241 5258 1 5258 1 100% [1], [2], [3], [4]
Sh 2-242 1967 1 1967 1 100% [1], [2]
Sh 2-247 2027 1 2027 1 100% [1], [2], [3]
Sh 2-253 4540 1 4540 1 100% [1], [2]
Sh 2-261 2041 1 2041 1 100% [1], [2], [3]
Sh 2-263 529 1 529 1 100% [1]
Sh 2-264 279 1 279 1 100% [1], [2]
Sh 2-266 5523 1 5523 1 100% [1]
Sh 2-268 1141 1 1141 1 100% [1], [2]
Sh 2-27 181 1 181 1 100% [1]
Sh 2-28 2099 1 2099 1 100% [1], [2]
Sh 2-280 1488 1 1488 1 100% [1], [2]
Sh 2-283 6794 1 6794 1 100% [1], [2], [3]
Sh 2-298 4319 1 4319 1 100% [1]
Sh 2-302 2135 1 2135 1 100% [1], [2], [3]
Sh 2-32 1590 1 1590 1 100% [1]
Sh 2-44 1823 1 1823 1 100% [1]
Sh 2-46 1421 1 1421 1 100% [1]
Sh 2-54 1976 1 1976 1 100% [1], [2]
Sh 2-61 2390 1 2390 1 100% [1], [2]
Sh 2-7 150 1 150 1 100% [1]
Sh 2-72 1693 1 1693 1 100% [1]
Sh 2-80 6203 1 6203 1 100% [1]
Sh 2-82 846 1 846 1 100% [1]
Sh 2-85 484 1 484 1 100% [1]
Sh 2-90 2266 1 2266 1 100% [1]
Ori-Eri Bubble 396 15 396 15 100% [1]
Sh 2-119 787 6 877 5 83% [1], [2], [3]
Sh 2-131 956 17 953 14 82% [1], [2]
RCW 53 2503 51 2405 41 80% [1]
Sh 2-8 1754 20 1734 16 80% [1], [2], [3]
RCW 99 2396 5 2428 4 80% [1], [2], [3]
Sh 2-137 470 5 705 4 80% [1], [2], [3]
Sh 2-199 2039 5 2028 4 80% [1], [2], [3]
Sh 2-236 3785 5 3798 4 80% [1], [2], [3], [4], [5], [6]
Sh 2-297 1125 5 1103 4 80% [1], [2]
Sh 2-11 1617 28 1577 21 75% [1], [2], [3], [4]
Sh 2-273 772 12 764 9 75% [1]
Sh 2-230 2811 4 2820 3 75% [1]
Sh 2-296 1138 4 1133 3 75% [1], [2]
RCW 62 2527 7 2519 5 71% [1]
Sh 2-190 2171 9 2072 6 66% [1], [2], [3]
Sh 2-49 1961 9 1778 6 66% [1], [2]
DWB 68 1023 3 1026 2 66% [1]
Ge 68 2820 3 2820 2 66% [1]
Gum 37 3254 3 2953 2 66% [1], [2], [3]
m Cen nebula 2314 3 2183 2 66% [1]
RCW 102 3723 3 4055 2 66% [1], [2]
RCW 130 1227 3 1108 2 66% [1], [2]
RCW 33 1011 3 1011 2 66% [1], [2]
RCW 35 1680 3 1857 2 66% [1], [2]
Sh 2-295 1283 3 1269 2 66% [1]
Sh 2-31 1072 3 1072 2 66% [1]
Sh 2-88 2084 3 2005 2 66% [1], [2], [3]
Sh 2-45 1664 11 1678 7 63% [1], [2]
Sh 2-101 1936 5 1993 3 60% [1], [2], [3]
Sh 2-140 1069 5 937 3 60% [1], [2], [3]
Sh 2-30 1140 5 1529 3 60% [1], [2]
Sh 2-281 404 5 417 3 60% [1], [2], [3]
RCW 55 4606 4 4606 2 50% [1], [2], [3]
RCW 61 4097 4 2743 2 50% [1], [2]
Sh 2-108 1695 4 1478 2 50% [1], [2]
Sh 2-145 1089 4 982 2 50% [1], [2]
Sh 2-35 1668 4 1668 2 50% [1], [2]
Gum 12 337 2 342 1 50% [1]
RCW 129 180 2 145 1 50% [1]
RCW 146b 2770 2 1558 1 50% [1], [2]
RCW 38 2125 2 1740 1 50% [1]
RCW 48 2989 2 1960 1 50% [1]
RCW 68 2259 2 1924 1 50% [1]
RCW 83 2069 2 1881 1 50% [1]
RCW 85 1916 2 1605 1 50% [1], [2]
Sh 2-1 1445 2 179 1 50% [1]
Sh 2-220 758 2 381 1 50% [1]
Sh 2-289 2814 2 5534 1 50% [1]
Sh 2-292 731 2 1333 1 50% [1]
Sh 2-301 3790 2 4451 1 50% [1]
Sh 2-310 4000 2 1508 1 50% [1], [2]
Sh 2-37 1386 2 1536 1 50% [1], [2], [3]
Sh 2-64 681 2 566 1 50% [1]
Sh 2-87 1555 2 2310 1 50% [1], [2], [3]
Sh 2-171 1107 4 1039 2 50% [1]
DWB 34 1693 7 1693 3 42% [1]
Sh 2-41 1875 7 1875 3 42% [1]
Sh 2-129 1256 5 834 2 40% [1]
Sh 2-202 1029 5 819 2 40% [1], [2]
Sh 2-284 3869 13 4663 5 38% [1], [2], [3], [4], [5]
Gum 34b 6749 3 3450 1 33% [1]
RCW 106 2088 3 2088 1 33% [1]
RCW 20 4448 3 3607 1 33% [1]
RCW 49 3208 3 5805 1 33% [1]
RCW 50 2684 3 4052 1 33% [1]
RCW 74 2252 3 3707 1 33% [1], [2]
Sh 2-115 1704 3 2701 1 33% [1], [2], [3]
Sh 2-132 4542 3 4146 1 33% [1]
Sh 2-249 2384 3 2012 1 33% [1], [2]
RCW 105 4094 5 2115 1 20% [1], [2]

Some Like It Hot, Part 4: A face-on map within 3kpc using Gaia DR2

Submitted by Kevin Jardine on 26 April, 2018 - 17:39
Face-on map of Milky Way detail
A detail from a face-on map of the Milky Way within 3kpc (about 10 thousand light years). The full map is is available available as a PDF here.

Now that Gaia DR2 is available, it is possible to do an enormous amount of mapping and stellar analysis, much of which is announced on Twitter via the #GaiaDR2 hash tag.

I have used the two data sets I mentioned in my last two blog posts (The Humphreys/Blaha catalog of luminous stars and the expanded Avedisova catalog of ionizing stars for HII regions) to create a simple map of the Milky Way out to 3kpc (about ten thousand light years). It is available as a PDF here.

There is a lot of detail on the map, so you will need to zoom into 100% to see it. In general I used the Sharpless, Gum, Georgelin and RCW names for the HII regions, following Avedisova, which are not necessarily the most commonly used names today. At some point I will do a version with expanded labels.

Blue dots are OB and Wolf Rayet stars. Magenta dots are cooler stars. The yellow dot at the centre is the Sun. Red circles are HII regions.

I filtered the GaiaDR2 cross matches to only select stars with err/parallax < 0.2. This found roughly two-thirds of the stars in the data sets. If I spent more time on the cross matches I could probably find more.

This is very much a draft map. There are many possibilities for errors with this kind of map: errors in the ionizing stars for specific HII regions, bad cross matches, etc.

Also, a better map would be based on Gaia DR2 star density and not just a specific list of stars. And would be 3D. All of that is under development by myself and others. Expect to see some amazing Milky Way maps over the next few weeks and months!

Some Like It Hot, Part 3: Ionizing stars of HII regions

Submitted by Kevin Jardine on 25 April, 2018 - 09:48
HII region star catalog detai
A detail from the catalog of ionizing stars for HII regions. A full all sky image in galactic coordinates is available here.

In 1984, Avedisova and Kondratenko published an important paper Exciting stars and the distances of the diffuse nebulae [ADS link: 1984NInfo..56...59A] in which they listed several hundred ionizing stars for HII regions.

Although the paper is written in Russian, the tables are provided in Roman characters.

Over the last few years I have expanded the Avedisova ionizing star catalog to include data from about 90 other scientific papers as part of a project to determine the ionizing stars for the major visible HII regions. I am making this expanded catalog available today in preparation for the Gaia DR2 release (expected in just a few hours now!). It contains more than 500 stars.

You can download the ionizing star catalog as a zip here. The catalog includes a reference to the scientific paper for each star, a SIMBAD identifier, the HII region it ionizes and, crucially, a cross match identifier for 2MASS or Tycho-2 so that parallaxes can be retrieved via the Gaia DR2 cross match tables.

In addition, the zip includes a table giving basic parameters for each HII region, including the galactic longitude and latitude, and the radius of the region in the sky in arcminutes.

Interestingly, the Avedisova catalog of ionizing stars was finished in the same year (1984) as the Humphreys/Blaha catalog of luminous stars I mentioned in my last blog post. This may not be entirely a coincidence. In some ways these catalogs were a culmination of a period from about 1970 to 1985 when astronomers were intensely interested in mapping optically visible objects in the Milky Way. After 1985, interest moved to non-visual frequencies and more astrophysical topics like dark matter or the age of the universe.

It seems clear that the release of Gaia DR2 today is likely to spark a new period of interest in mapping the Milky Way, making the Avedisova and Humphreys/Blaha catalogs very relevant again.

If you are interested in learning more about luminous stars or HII regions, please read The Cloud Hunters and The Star Sweepers for more information.

Some Like It Hot, Part 2: The Humphreys catalog of luminous stars

Submitted by Kevin Jardine on 24 April, 2018 - 09:25
Humphreys catalog detail
A detail from the Humphreys catalog of luminous stars. A full all sky image in galactic coordinates is available here.

Roberta Humphreys first published her catalog of luminous stars in her highly cited 1978 paper, Studies of luminous stars in nearby galaxies. I. Supergiants and O stars in the Milky Way [ADS link: 1978ApJS...38..309H].

The catalog was further refined by Cindy Blaha and colleagues and divided into two sections on luminous stars in associations and field stars. There are about 5000 stars in total.

The catalog was completed in 1984 and eventually made available for download from several locations, including NASA and ADS servers. However, over time the catalog disappeared from these servers and for some reason does not appear to have been uploaded to Vizier.

You can click here to download a zip of the catalog files here, along with a SIMBAD cross match I did recently. The cross match includes ids for existing star catalogs like 2MASS, Tycho and UCAC4. The Gaia DR2 dataset will include best neighbour cross matches for these catalogs when it is released, so the cross match file can be used to look up parallaxes for these stars.

I was able to find cross matches for almost all the stars in the Humphreys catalog and will put up a simple face on map of the data set after Gaia DR2 is released. For now you can click here to download an image of the data in the sky with galactic coordinates. Blue dots are O, B and Wolf-Rayet stars. Red dots are cooler stars.

Some Like It Hot, Part 1: Gaia and the ionizing stars

Submitted by Kevin Jardine on 23 April, 2018 - 10:14
Movie poster
Movie poster

Some Like It Hot is a classic comedy written and directed by Billy Wilder, starring Marilyn Monroe, Jack Lemmon and Tony Curtis.

I'm borrowing the title for a series of blog posts starting this week, the week of the Gaia DR2 release. With more than 1 billion parallax estimates extending throughout a quarter of the Milky Way disk and far into the halo, Gaia DR2 is a momentous event in the history of astronomy. For the first time we will be able to map a large portion of our galaxy in amazing detail.

There are two approaches to producing maps using Gaia DR2. One is a full 3D approach visualizing the dataset using star density meshes. The second is to map favourite lists of stars.

I am working on both types of maps. For this week, the second approach is faster and easier.

I have two favourite lists, both of very hot stars. The first was produced by Roberta Humphreys in the 1970s and extended in the 1980s by her graduate student Cynthia Blaha. It lists about 5000 extremely luminous stars. Most are ionizing stars: they are so hot that they rip apart any hydrogen atoms in their vicinity.

The second is a smaller list of about 500 stars, all ionizing stars that are known to be associated with HII regions: large regions of ionized hydrogen gas.

Ionizing stars are one of the main markers of the spiral arms. By mapping these data sets, we can get some insight into the local spiral structure.

Moreover, both of these data sets are self-labelling. The Humphreys and Blaha data set lists OB associations for about half their stars. The HII region data set contains the ionizing stars for many famous nebulae, including the Orion, Lagoon, and Carina regions among many others. We can map the positions of these nebulae if we can map their ionizing stars.

So if we map these data sets, we should get an instant face-on map of our region of the galaxy. Over the next few days I'll describe these data sets in more detail and after the Gaia release, I'll show the resulting face-on maps.

As I said, a more ambitious project would be a full 3D map based on star density. I'll be working on that as well but it will take more time to produce.

Pages

Subscribe to RSS - Kevin Jardine's blog